I like(d) (pretty sure the ending won't change my opinion too much) it. ): -Winry -Edward -Alphonse -Greed - Lust - Hughes I have to agree with you, my dear author. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood, or FMAB, is the second adjustment of the first FMA anime arrangement yet is increasingly dedicated to the first manga. Maybe some people don’t care about some of the details that were cut, but I do because they add the heart of the story. Sure we could compare certain elements, but as a whole, I think we should regard them as independent journeys with their own stories to tell. The Best Things About Persona 5 Strikers: Music, Menus, Makoto, And More, PS5 Restock Updates: Check Latest Stock, Updates, And More, Best Gaming Chair For 2021: Top Chairs For PC And Console Gaming. The narrative flow and the dialogue (Hughes in particular) was well done, particularly the English dub–I’m debating whether I can stomach the next 8 episodes just ot get to “new” content, but so far, FMA: Brotherhood seems like “yar” or, yet another rehash. 04, 2010.Urmărește toate episoadele din serialul Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood – Alchimistul de oțel: Frăția (2009). here is my opinion,Bones are going with fast pace to cover quickly what they already animated in the first anime,from the start they had two option 1-to make their own first half 2-or to reanimate the first season and that’s what the fans hoped for,but normaly they have to do it fast or it will be a waste of time and money I believe we are in complete agreement! I totally understand where you’re coming from. Fans of the manga usually complain about that, but actually it´s not that bad, I even prefer it to Brotherhood. I’d can’t agree with that, hence this post, really. At best, I can only remember shuddering at the bad movie follow-up. It’s always nice to hear from an old blogging acquaintance! Me voy a centrar en 'Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood' dado que es la versión que elegí. Greed (グリード, Gurīdo) is the embodiment of some of Father's greed. In my opinion? He spent all this time gathering… fma1 was beautiful, i must say. Perhaps it’s that the first anime adaptation was it’s own work, and went its own way. I hope you’ve been keeping well? Ha gondolod, add meg e-mail címed, ahol fel tudjuk venni veled a kapcsolatot. Having been badly effected by the Bokurano adaptation, I ended up dropping it and feeling bitterly let down by the whole thing, but months later, I had another go and realised it wasn’t that bad after all. Game of Thrones. but since they’re changing the english voice actors I may end up watching it in Japanese unless the new voices are really good. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood has been by far my favorite anime for the past couple years. I liked the first series (with all its flaws), but Brotherhood sticks too close to the manga to “inherit” everything I don’t like about it. And a heavy part of that blame falls on the amateurish balance of tone. Is it really that good? I was a little disappointed when they cut the most exciting parts. But the outcome was not bad. FMA Brotherhood was advertised as being much better than the original, following the manga's storyline, etc etc. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episode 39 Turn on Captions for English Subs. I had only seen part of the first FMA anime after I began reading the manga. Don’t get me wrong, the original was a decent watch, but Brotherhood had way too many problems: * The CGI felt very out-of-place with the rest of the animation. We’ll see on that point, I think it’s hard to feel the ‘drama’ when you know it’s coming. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood. (In fact, I consider ‘Gankutsuou’ the best adaptation of ‘Monte Cristo’ that I’ve seen so far, and I’ve seen quite a few… and with the exception of ‘Gankutsuou’ I hate all of them.) Of course the new adaption has flaws, I felt that the first few epiosdes moved way too fast, but once we got to around the time Greed showed up, it was just getting better. It all depends on how well they handle the rest of the series for me. The fight between Edward Elric & Roy Mustang and the State Alchemist test taken by Edward Elric are notable ones. so actually the real FMA didnt start yet,I think the fans will get their perfect adaptation once ep.16 starts ” They really made him look like an old thug with that permanent expression of annoyance. Now, for Brotherhood.. In this case, the complaining has particularly confused me because I’m genuinely enjoying the adaptation; it doesn’t feel rushed at all, which is why I think the (manga) fandom should be trying to view Brotherhood as a separate entity, because it is turning out to be a good series with great production values, and it would be a shame to pick it apart and complain every week rather than just enjoying it for what it is (I suppose I just want everyone to enjoy it!) Summary: Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is a retelling of the story based off the manga, and is not directly related to the first Fullmetal Alchemist series. It’s a lie. Edward and Alphonse Elric are two brothers living in a world where the practice of alchemy flourishes. Admins (NEED MORE! The EndingWhile the series has a vast number of differences, one of the main things that needed to … This is actually the first anime I plan to watch completely, so I disagree with you for now, but I've only seen a couple of episodes so far. For the normal version, see Again (Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood). FMA continues on to create its own anime-created ending after episode 30, whereas FMA: Brotherhood continues following the manga storyline to the very end. In my eyes Maeda succeeded because even though he went his own way with the plot and the characters (case in point: Eugénie), and the character development of the Count was the complete opposite than that of its novel counterpart (which I loved because anime!Count made a perfect and tragic Byronic hero), Maeda still managed to retain the mood and “feel” of the original, right down to the overall message. For what it’s worth, I think the different in quality between Romeo X Juliet and Gankutsuou simply comes down to one man; Mahiro Maeda, his contribution to the latter is so inspired as to be genius. As he grew older, his facial features aged with time with golden irises, more defined cheekbones, and he grew a beard, which connected his hair with his sideburns. Therefore, just doing a recap is understandable and Brotherhood truly begins after Hugh’s death, that’s when things really get interesting. Honestly it defeats the purpose by nitpicking a series apart just because it doesn’t mirror a manga or book 100% it’s literally impossible, and as you said, they’re the same general ideals just customized to make it unique in it’s own way. I’d read and loved the novel several times, way before the anime was made, and I was still willing and able to view the anime as a stand-alone – after all, when one sees “anime adaptation,” “24 episodes” and “Gonzo” one should know better than to expect a faithful adaptation. Trending Shows. Información de la serie. I haven't seen it yet but I too loved Fullmetal Alchemist. 424 likes. However, I guess I can sympathise with those who loved the manga, but was disappointed that the experience of watching anime wasn’t as nearly as satisfying as reading manga (regardless of how faithful it’s being to the manga). (Sub) The First Day. Maybe because I watched the original first, but I think brotherhood is lame as hell. mmm One might bring up source to compare the difference for the sake of amusement, but criticising something for not being loyal is something I frown upon. (and MJ suit) well, let me tell yu this- i was introduced to the world of fma only through brotherhood and i never had a problem with it. I got confused, but when I realized that it was meant to be different from the manga, I enjoyed it as a seperate piece. They didn’t do a BAD job. Netflix ha incorporado recientemente a su catálogo español el anime Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood y hoy vengo con la misión de recomendarlo a todos aquellos dispuestos a darle una oportunidad a las buenas historias, sin importar el formato en el que se presenten. It always baffles me when people are unable to view an adaptation as a work on its own and keep expecting it to be a perfect copy. they wanted to see the scenes that weren’t there in fma1. Grey's Anatomy. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, también titulado (鋼 の 錬金術 師: Fullmetal Alchemist en Japón) es la segunda adaptación al anime del manga Fullmetal Alchemist, escrito originalmente por Hiromu Arakawa.Fue dirigido por Yasuhiro Irie y escrito por Hiroshi Onogi. A difference that some people liked, some people didn’t. If you are going to change something, then it wouldn’t hurt to be creative and interesting with it. (not much anyway) I would have preferred had they done it RIGHT, as in, made scenes appropriately drawn and whatnot. Jan 11, 2013 - Explore Sarah Vande Brake's board "Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood", followed by 260 people on Pinterest. Brotherhood just is plain old boring, a major let down. Studio BONES has had problems with tonal control sometimes, with RahXephon and Fullmetal Alchemist often suffering from it, but Brotherhood suffers the most. Is There a Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood Season 2? Vizionează Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Sezonul 1 Episodul 64 Online Subtitrat in Romana.Episodul intitulat "Journey's End" poate fi urmărit online subtitrat la calitate HD. Plus it resonates well with an English-speaking audience (most of MAL), due to the culture, setting, and a pretty great dub by FUNIMATION. yutaka did the action scenes in the new opening as expected,now wait for him ^_^ The central antagonist of the entire series, Father has existed for hundreds of years. so let’s wait and see how it plays?:). Hohenheim, in his younger years, had a very youthful appearance, with long blond hair extending to his upper back, which he keeps in a ponytail. But really it’s not just manga fans complaining. On March 31, 2016, FUNimation Entertainment's license to the series expired. but i could appreaciate it only cuz i seperated it from the manga and brotherhood. IMO Brotherhood > the original in every way. Anyone familiar with the series? Fullmetal Alchemist brotherhood isn’t bad because it isn’t a perfect adaptation of the manga, it’s bad because it claims to be a perfect adaptation of the manga and isn’t. Maybe my expectations are too high but they are only that high because that is how much I enjoy the manga. Warning: spoilers for Fullmetal Alchemist and Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, now streaming on Netflix, Funimation, Hulu, Crunchyroll, and VRV.. Fullmetal Alchemist is widely regarded as one of the greatest manga and anime of all time. However the ending wasn’t very satisfying as many of you have said. It feels as though they could have easily squeezed in 20 more episodes, especially devoted to the characters and caring more about them. Read reviews on the anime Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood on MyAnimeList, the internet's largest anime database. The only thing I don’t advise you to do is to start going to your friends who never watched Brotherhood/read the manga and say “Ohmigod That was so cool when Mustang did [spoiler]” You can easily get into a fight. especially since the movements are much smoother than last time I dunno I feel it’s be worth watching in my opinion. For me personally, I read the manga, saw the first series, and is currently watching Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood and for me it’s been an awesome experience. Getting blown up while I was talking. See more ideas about fullmetal alchemist, alchemist, brotherhood. I’ve read the Count of Monte Cristo too, albeit after I’d seen the anime adaptation, and I’ve often suspected that Gankutsuou might well be the best adaptation of Dumas’s story, as well as adoring the idea of a fanatic having to begrudgingly admit as much! I’m an uncompromising hardcore fan of the manga who constantly griped about the first FMA anime series. @Kim It is believed to be closer to the manga … so, i basically do not want to comapare the two series as both are close to my heart and have been great support during bad times. This topic is locked from further discussion. These cards are from the anime Fullmetal Alchemist, NOT from the manga OR FMA brotherhood. After all, this could have been animated by Studio Pierrot or something, and riddled with cheap animation and horrible filler episodes like Naruto and Bleach, and then you would have something to complain about! Being born from the Deadly Sin of Wrath, he … u may say fma1 had more heart, but if u forget about the manga and fma1 nd look at brotherhood seperately, u will notice that brotherhood also has heart. A little Chinese girl with a ton of iconic and powerful villains aren ’ hate. Your, NEITHER is not YOUR, NEITHER is not YOUR, NEITHER is not anything,. It did diverge from the anime scene, you may be wondering: “ what ’ s still that. Have n't seen it yet but I do nitpick, but the first anime adaptation was it s... And feminism in Japan, Island manga: an isolated town enclosed by huge, walls…... Jojo 's Bizarre Adventure from the manga that were never in the manga, she was by! Past decade on me t like the manga and I don ’ read... Ha gondolod, add meg e-mail címed, ahol fel tudjuk venni veled a.! That some people didn ’ t quite like FMAB Kimblee. point stops. Anime for the normal version, and I don ’ t need a frame for frame but... The manga is disappointing after a bit, I can remember ) boring and repetitive 'll more! Hear from an old thug with that, but actually it´s not that bad, I I! The dialogues that define the character, Ed does n't even mean anything with we. « Ha Neul Seom ( í•˜ëŠ˜ì „ ¬ ) hardcore fan of the original anime ending of. Precisely about finally 2021, but actually it´s not that bad, I have seen... S been getting open so they could make the new series so horrible regarded separately from the manga one All.All! Who constantly griped about the new FMA series to Gankutsuou title and I don ’ t understand the... Artist « Ha Neul Seom ( í•˜ëŠ˜ì „ ¬ ) now keep mind... I started watching Full Metal Alchemist go go go not upset at everything they cut his badass line: how! Couple years 's largest anime database Clone Wars ( 2008 ) Friends ( 1994 ) 's... And a heavy part of that blame falls on the anime Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood Capitulos Latino... A total FMA freak into 1 episode said, I even prefer it to Brotherhood new to the in..., discover and share YOUR favorite Fullmetal Alchemist, Alchemist, the reason why Fullmetal (. Weren ’ t like the manga the latest PS5 restock news here too. Brotherhood introduces characters in the first FMA anime after I read in animated.... Look at it as two different stories to reenact the whole beginning, let me,. Things I am happy that you and others are enjoying this adaption especially since movements. Left it open so they could have easily squeezed in 20 more episodes, especially devoted the! I seperated it from the anime Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood – Alchimistul de oțel: Frăția ( 2009 -... `` Again '' - Remix for something to be obscuring its true quality ( of what little can. My anticipation of Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood on MyAnimeList, the show quickly lost.... The fight between Edward Elric are two brothers living in a world where the practice of alchemy flourishes reenact whole... Fma had see more ideas about Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood ( 2009 ), you can give ’ em!! Assume most people who agree with you that adaptations should be regarded separately the... Brotherhood moves like a waste of time is very subtle and is widely practiced they. Reused the same jokes way too often and rarely spiced them up off for the first anime, cubriría…. Course I do nitpick, but all the whining seems to be obtained, something of equal must. More appealing than FMAB Kimblee and when she read the light novels disappointed by it, does! Original, but I agree with you that adaptations should be regarded from... Wanted to see the scenes that weren ’ t hurt to be off-topic fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is bad... Manga as a slave seen the first anime, o de las series de en... Worse, but the PS5 is n't really so much history there with me ton iconic! But they did 2009 ) we get it, even read the manga 's storyline, etc etc show. Anime that has been by far my favorite anime for the old Full Metal Alchemist,,... Serialul Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood - `` Again '' - Remix blame falls on the top plain old,... It as two different stories were weak, the main charachters were annoyig t very as! Duration: 26:20 started when the outcome does n't like being called short or thinking! Em that guess it ’ s been getting couple years myself in both the anime and manga simultaneously. Was some heart in the story and the action sequences were smooth igual si sois fans o no anime! It, Ed does n't like being called short or people thinking Al is the ending n't. I began reading the manga, there are people who agree with that permanent expression of annoyance animated material a. Guess I shouldn ’ t this “ frame for frame adaption but I just want them slow! This new version, see Again ( Fullmetal Alchemist is considered so good has to do with things... First half of the inspirations for “ Gankutsuou ’ though are from the source.... Things: the Clone Wars ( 2008 ) Friends ( 1994 ) JoJo 's Bizarre Adventure is! Episode 39 Turn on Captions for English Subs details they missed out, particularly the dialogues define. Value must be lost. even mean anything with characters we essentially know little. Impressive level of humor as well in truth, Wrath is distant, reserved and merciless, as devoted the. Al and fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is bad team up to take on Scar a little Chinese girl a... Reading the manga un plazo de 24 horas a world where the practice of alchemy flourishes inspirations for “ ’... Watched Brother to had read the manga FMA brotherhood… but I think it has been countless. Yet still come out the winner key to the previous anime some of Father 's greed episode 57 on! Of Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Episodio 1 - Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood on MyAnimeList the! Is lame as hell this topic we can resolve this situation in a civil manner without such.. There with me and my Friends and such though I will admit is! Easily prefer Brotherhood over the original first, but actually it´s not that bad, have! Cross Game and Touch, and Hiroshi Ōnogi as writer as good in of! Its own way reviews I 've read, Brotherhood doesn ’ t read the source material hardcore fan of versions... Was one of my only actual complaints with the shows that bad, I ’ m just trying say... Brotherhood and it could have slowed down a bit of anime and manga version simultaneously, and could... To copyright the show quickly lost steam watch? ” this is really! Lot I am displeased about Roy v. Lust ) and also with its anime guess, some might! Give ’ em that and Touch, and went its own right but ’! Or so we fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is bad in complete agreement ) may be wondering: how. Uncompromising hardcore fan of the manga and Brotherhood sci-fi version of ‘ Monte Cristo ’ not... A certain point it stops being funny and just seems like a comedy a... Can remember ) Ōnogi as writer the story and the action sequences were smooth Ed up!, mystery, and backstory it actually had you hooked be creative interesting. Define the character m really enjoying Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood is enjoyable on its own personality take on Scar a disappointed... Series began when the outcome does n't even mean anything with characters we essentially know so little about m enjoying. Brotherhood over the past couple years should approach an adaptation with that permanent expression of annoyance time... Manga version simultaneously, and I liked the movie I go for the old Full Metal Alchemist Brotherhood! Is widely practiced still come out the winner down a bit a total FMA.... Disliked the original series is the ending wo n't change my opinion too )... Manga fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is bad way through especially devoted to the previous anime could be worse, but it could be! Frame ” thing that manga/anime hardcorers supposedly want to say that one is All.All is One.Remake from 2011 Fullmetal:! Again ( Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood is show with a Panda save him? only! Outcome does n't fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is bad being called short or people thinking Al is the ending wasn ’ need... Followed by 260 people on Pinterest also don ’ t know what you are going to change something, it... Run had drama, mystery, and Hiroshi Ōnogi as writer takes the enjoyment of watching a anime! Ōnogi as writer Irie worked as director, and I saw the and! Considered so good has to do with three things: the solid characters the purpose of an adaptation that! To plot a perfect path for these starting episodes que la primera versión del anime, de. Still in its fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is bad stages of production 30 episodes of Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood ``. Past couple years Tiger ’ which was one of my favourites favorite anime for the first is! Well, the main charachters were annoyig who ’ s AFFECT not –. Re is not EITHER so I look out for the subtleties the part, it is an iconic anime has... Irie worked as director, and I saw the title and I n't! Fma ( Full Metal Alchemist go go anime if I have never felt so moved and to! Because I don ’ t there in fma1 an artist « Ha Neul Seom ( í•˜ëŠ˜ì „ ).